Brad and I went out two nights ago with Nick and Ada, the impossibly young/earnest neighbors who are fast becoming our BFFs. Once at the bar, we fell into the usual couples-getting-to-know-each-other routine – Nick and Brad stood at the bar and had a drinking contest, while Ada and I sat at a table and had a “Who used to be sluttier?” contest. (And yeah, I won. I always win. Three-plus years of serial dating in New York City have left me with stories that no 22 year-old could even hope to beat… and I suppose I should be embarrassed, but instead I just feel grateful that I’m still an overachiever at something.)
After fifteen minutes we’d stopped trying to out-slut each other, and started trading Most Embarrassing Moment Stories. The guys sat down just as Ada finished telling me about the time that she’d farted in the bed and then pretended that the smell was coming from a dead squirrel in one of their heating vents.
I knew it was time to bust out the big guns.
“Ok,” I said, “I have the world’s worst story.”
The World’s Worst Story
No, wait. I’m going to stop here, for a moment, and just admit the truth: this is not my story. Rather, it is the story of a friend of a friend. But it is a TRUE story, and it is so terrible, so unutterably poignant and gut-wrenching, that it loses nothing in the retelling.
And now, really, here it is...
The World’s Worst Story, For Real This Time
Emily was a typical 20something, single girl – living in a big city (Paris, in this case), working her way up the corporate ladder, and looking for love in the meantime. She was frustrated, as so many women have been before her, by her inability to connect with anyone. Date after date, she struggled to find the right guy, only to end up alone in her apartment with another bleak, solitary dawn approaching.
So she was thrilled when, during a night out with friends, she met Philip.
Philip was handsome, charming, and successful. He was also that rarest of big-city specimens, a genuinely nice guy. The two of them talked all night. He asked for her phone number, and then, he called the next day to ask her out on a proper date.
The night of their date, Philip picked her up at her apartment, and took her to dinner where, again, they spent hours talking. By the end of the evening, Emily felt she’d known him forever. Not only that, she could tell that he felt the same. And when he invited her back to his apartment, she didn’t hesitate; she went home with him, where they had ecstatic, mind-blowingly good sex and then fell asleep in each other’s arms.
The next morning, Emily woke to Philip – fully dressed in a wonderfully-tailored suit – kissing her gently on the cheek.
“You looked so peaceful, I didn’t want to wake you,” he said. He gazed adoringly at her while he told her that he had to go to work, but that she should sleep late, make herself comfortable, and leave whenever she liked—the door would simply lock behind her automatically, leaving her free to wake up at her leisure.
“Okay,” she said, and Philip kissed her goodbye and left, promising to call her that evening.
Alone in Philip’s apartment, Emily was giddy. She’d done it – she’d made a real connection, had had a wonderful first date with a beautiful man. He was perfect. Even his apartment was perfect, with mahogany furniture and luxuriant hardwood floors and a marble bathroom.
It was in the marble bathroom that Emily ran into trouble.
Of course, it’s never wise to do a Number Two in a stranger’s bathroom – particularly a stranger with whom you hope to have a romantic future. Too many things can go wrong.
In Emily’s case, the toilet wouldn’t flush.
She jiggled the handle, growing more panicky by the minute as the toilet remained un-flushed. A foray into the depths of the tank did nothing to alleviate the situation. Finally, knowing that desperate action was called for, Emily did the only thing she could think of: she got a plastic bag from the kitchen, retrieved the Number Two from the toilet, tied the bag shut, and put it by the front door next to her purse. She would bring the bag with her and deposit it in a public trash bin on the street. It was gross, yes, but it was the only way.
As she finished dressing and putting on her makeup, she even allowed herself to feel a tiny measure of triumph. Lesser women might have panicked, but not her – she’d gotten the job done, whatever it took. Problem solved. There was a bounce in her step as she fluffed her hair, picked up her purse, and cast a last look around the apartment before closing the door behind her.
You know what’s next, don’t you?
She left the shit.
Just inside the door; an unmistakable little accent in the foyer for him to discover upon his return.
Philip never called her again.
In a way, Emily was grateful.
* * *
Ada and Nick shrieked when I finished the story, as people always do, but then she leaned against his chest and looked up at him with adoring eyes.
“Nick, would you still love me if I left a plastic bag of shit in your apartment?” she said.
He looked down at her with such unrestrained, oozing love that I thought he might lick her face.
“Of course I would, honey,” he said.