Before we begin, let me just clarify that this breakup story is 1) anecdotal, and 2) utterly unrelated to an actual romantic relationship -- a fact that I only mention in case anybody reading is highly emotionally invested in my possible future as Mrs. Brad. (Not that I can fathom why anyone would be, unless you are Brad, in which case don't worry. And also, could you please wash your towel because it is making the entire bathroom smell like balls.)And now, let's begin.
Dear readers, have you ever found yourself dating someone who, though fun at times, was something of a dud overall?
And you always planned to end it… eventually?
But somehow you didn’t get around to it, and then suddenly the
dud dumps
you, and you’re all, “What the…?!”, and the dud is all, “You never supported my dreams,” and you’re all, “I will eternally regret that I did not dump you first, you stupid dud,” and then the dud begins dating someone who looks
just like you except not as cute?
Well, that TOTALLY happened to me. Except that it was five guys, not one, and they were bandmates, not boyfriends.
If you’ve been reading for awhile, you might remember that – once upon a time – I mentioned singing in a band. I did this for two years, until last April, when I was unceremoniously dumped via email without a word of warning. (Dumped is the word, too – musician relationships are just as fraught as dating ones. It is with good reason that, when a band’s members tire of making music together and go their separate ways, it’s referred to as a “breakup”.)
In my case, though, the band itself didn’t break up. Instead, they went on without me, and after a few months their website announced that they’d found a new singer – a petite brunette, just like me. A soprano, just like me.
Even coupled with the schadenfreude that came from seeing how shitty their e-newsletter had become since my departure (in addition to fronting the band, I wrote all their news and website copy), my irritation couldn’t outweigh my hurt feelings.
It wasn’t so much that I’d wanted to be in the band forever. As much fun as it was, and as loyal a following as we had from a particular demographic in New York, we just weren’t that good. Also, as I found myself in a serious relationship, my interest in playing the role of Onstage Singing Sex Object for a band of guys who kept pressuring me to “Dress sluttier next time!” was starting to wane.
But I had expected, as any fully-invested collaborator would, as any
friend would, that my departure from the project would at least merit a conversation. It was a relationship like any other; didn’t the rules of common decency apply? To return to the dating metaphor – what kind of asshole ends a two-year relationship, out of the blue,
via e-mail?
So even though it wasn’t a romantic breakup, I started indulging in classic breakup behavior: haunting the band’s myspace page, talking shit about them to anyone who would listen, simultaneously hoping and fearing that I’d see one of my former bandmates on the street and give him a piece of my mind.
But eventually, of course, the pain went away. By the time I did run into my former bassist on the way home from work, I was over it enough to give him an emotionless stare and simply cross the street. And when the announcement went up that they were playing a show--their first gig since I’d left--at which the Singer Who Was Not Me would make her debut, I felt only the smallest twinge of pain in that old wound, the one created by my unceremonious dumping.
A small, small pain that has since been replaced by the exhilarating sensation of sweet, sweet revenge, when the following message (which I swear I did not write) appeared in their website guestbook the day after the show:
Could you find a more beautiful girl for vox? Your new singer is terrible!
The new singer has since quit.
And, like any self-respecting young woman whose boyfriend dumps her for another girl only to find himself single and embittered (and, on certain lucky occasions, infected with an STD) when the Other Girl screws
him over, I am watching from the sidelines.
And oh, boys, how I am
laughing.